When Bad Becomes Brilliant
The Guardian's review of the 2025 Count of Monte Cristo series opens with a delicious invitation: "Are you ready for some bad, fun TV made from a bad, fun book?" This refreshingly honest take on both Alexandre Dumas' melodramatic masterpiece and its latest adaptation reveals an important truth - sometimes the most entertaining television comes from embracing, not hiding, a story's inherent absurdity.
Let's be clear: calling The Count of Monte Cristo "bad" doesn't mean it lacks value. Rather, it acknowledges that Dumas wrote an outrageously over-the-top revenge fantasy filled with coincidences, melodrama, and plot twists that would make modern thriller writers blush. And that's exactly what makes it perfect for television.
Listen on Spotify
Experience the timeless wisdom of The Count of Monte Cristo through our professional audiobook narration. The skilled voice acting brings the novel's valuable life lessons to life, helping young readers absorb important teachings while remaining fully engaged with the story.
The Art of Pausing Every 45 Seconds
According to The Guardian, the new series "requires you to pause it every 45 seconds or so to shake your head at needless utterances." Examples include gems like "If we can't get through this storm, we'll perish" and Dantès declaring "I'd like to add two hours a day to my digging." This clunky dialogue might seem like a flaw, but it's actually part of the charm.
These "howling absurdities" create a unique viewing experience - one where you're simultaneously invested in the story and laughing at its execution. It's the television equivalent of a page-turner you can't put down, even as you roll your eyes at every plot twist.
Why "Bad" Works for Monte Cristo
The Source Material Demands It
Dumas' novel is 1,300 pages of pure melodrama. A faithful adaptation would include:
- A man escaping prison sewn into a body bag
- Secret identities maintained through increasingly ridiculous disguises
- Convenient coincidences that strain credibility
- Villains who practically twirl their mustaches
- A treasure that makes the protagonist impossibly wealthy overnight
Any adaptation that tried to play this completely straight would fail. The 2025 series succeeds by leaning into the absurdity.
Modern Audiences Crave Camp
In an era of prestige television that takes itself very seriously, there's something refreshing about a show that knows it's ridiculous. The Guardian review celebrates this self-awareness, noting that the series' stupidity "brings a joy of its own."
The Perfect Summer Binge
The Guardian positions this as ideal "high summer" viewing - when "the air is heavy with promise" and you want entertainment that doesn't require deep analysis. This isn't The Wire or Succession; it's pure escapist fun that happens to feature Jeremy Irons delivering dramatic monologues about buried treasure.
What Makes It Compulsively Watchable
Star Power Elevating Schlock
Jeremy Irons and Sam Claflin bring genuine talent to potentially ridiculous roles. Watching accomplished actors commit fully to melodramatic material creates a unique tension - are they in on the joke? Does it matter? Their performances ground the absurdity just enough to keep you invested.
Production Values vs. Script Quality
The series boasts impressive cinematography, authentic period costumes, and beautiful locations. This contrast between high production values and questionable dialogue creates an entertaining dissonance. It looks like prestige TV but sounds like a soap opera.
The Long Tradition of "Bad" Monte Cristo
This isn't the first Monte Cristo adaptation to embrace camp. The story has inspired:
- Over 30 film adaptations of varying quality
- Multiple TV series that prioritized drama over logic
- Stage productions that amp up the melodrama
- Even an anime that adds giant robots (really!)
Each generation gets the Monte Cristo it deserves, and 2025's version perfectly captures our current appetite for self-aware entertainment.
Why You Should Watch It Anyway
The Guardian review ends with anticipation: "I look forward to many more episodes." This enthusiasm for admittedly flawed television reveals an important truth - not everything needs to be high art to be worth watching.
The 2025 Count of Monte Cristo succeeds precisely because it fails at being serious prestige television. Instead, it delivers exactly what modern audiences need: a gloriously over-the-top revenge fantasy that knows exactly what it is. In a world of algorithmic content designed to be "good enough," there's something wonderful about television that's bad in all the right ways.
Embrace the Absurdity
So yes, you'll pause every 45 seconds to laugh at the dialogue. Yes, the plot requires enormous suspension of disbelief. Yes, the acting occasionally veers into camp. But that's not a bug - it's a feature. The 2025 Count of Monte Cristo proves that sometimes the best television is the kind that doesn't take itself too seriously, even when it's adapting one of literature's most enduring tales of revenge.
Pour yourself a glass of wine, settle in for a binge session, and prepare to enjoy every deliciously bad moment of this wonderfully entertaining adaptation. After all, as The Guardian suggests, it's exactly the kind of "bad, fun TV" we need right now.
